Jennifer Hudson Proposed to Punk

After Punk (OK, David Otunga) proposed to Jennifer Hudson on her birthday last September, she wanted to return the favor.

According to jewelry designer Neil Lane, Jennifer asked him to design an engagement ring, which she then presented to Punk on his birthday last month.

"Jennifer wanted to give him something really special when she asked David to marry her. It was very sentimental and romantic. They are really in love," he told People. "Jennifer and I went through lots of different designs, talked about it a lot and she was very open."

But the proposal didn't go as planned - the ring had to be returned to be re-sized because Punk has large (coughs, coughs) fingers.